factual

What conditions apply to a proposed transfer of a Benjamin Franklin Plumbing franchise agreement?

Benjamin_Franklin_Plumbing Franchise · 2025 FDD

Answer from 2025 FDD Document

e time period in Section 14.2 will run from the expiration, termination, or transfer of the Franchised Business or from the end of the individual's relationship with Franchisee, whichever occurs sooner.

  • 14.3.4 The time periods in Section 14.2 and Section 14.3.3 will be tolled for any period of time during which Franchisee or the restricted individual is in breach of the section and will resume only when Franchisee or such person begins or resumes compliance.
  • 14.3.5 The existence of any claim Franchisee or any Owner may have against Franchisor or its affiliates, whether or not arising under this Agreement, shall not constitute a defense to Franchisor's enforcement of the restrictions in this Section 14 or any separate confidentiality or non-competition agreement.
  • 14.3.6 You represent that Franchisee and each of its Owners possess skills and abilities of a general nature that provide them with other opportunities for employment and, therefore, our enforcement of the restrictions in Sections 14.2 and 14.3.3 will not deprive Franchisee or any of its Owners of their personal goodwill or ability to earn a living through alternative means.
  • 14.3.7 We have the right to reduce the scope of any restriction in this Section 14, effective immediately upon written notice to Franchisee.

15. SALE OR ASSIGNMENT

15.1. No Transfer of Interest without Our Consent. We have entered into this Agreement in reliance on the business skill, financial capacity, and personal character of Franchisee and its Owners. Accordingly, neither Franchisee nor the Owners may sell, assign, give away, pledge, or encumber, either voluntarily or by operation of law (such as through divorce or bankruptcy proceedings) any direct or indirect interest in this Agreement, in the assets of the Franchised Business, or in the equity ownership of Franchisee without obtaining our prior written consent. This Section applies to any transfer that would occur by any mechanism, including but not limited to family financial planning, estate planning, transfer to a trust, corporate reorganization, issuance or offering of securities, employee ownership plans, divorce, new marriage, bankruptcy, or receivership. If

Franchisee is a corporation, limited liability company, or other business entity, this Section also applies to the transfer of a direct or indirect ownership interest in Franchisee.

  • 15.1.1 We can approve or disapprove the proposed transferee in our sole discretion. If we approve the proposed transferee, we can still impose conditions on the transfer. Franchisee and the Owners agree that the conditions in Sections 15.2 through 15.7 below are reasonable and that they do not preclude other conditions that we may impose.
  • 15.1.2 Franchisee and the Owners agree to notify us in writing of each proposed transfer, to provide all information and documentation relating to the proposed transfer that we request, and to refrain from completing the transfer until we advise you that all requirements of this Section 15 have been satisfied. If we have not responded within sixty (60) days after receiving all requested information, we will be deemed to have refused consent.
  • 15.1.3 If you intend to execute a referral arrangement with a third-party (i.e., broker or investment bank) with whom we do not have a referral arrangement, then you are required to provide us with the name and contact information of the third-party prior to execution of the referral arrangement. We reserve the right to approve the third-party in our sole discretion. If your prior year's Gross Revenue is greater than five million dollars ($5,000,000), aggregated for all territories operated by Franchisee, then the third-party must be explicitly approved by us prior to engaging them to assist you or represent you with the transfer of your Franchised Business.
  • 15.1.4 We have the right to communicate with and counsel Franchisee, the Owners, and the proposed transferee on any aspect of a proposed transfer. Unless otherwise agreed, we do not waive any claims against the transferring party if we approve the transfer. If we do not approve the transfer, you are required to continue to operate the Franchised Business in accordance with this Agreement.
  • 15.2. Transfer of Business. The conditions set forth in this Section apply to a proposed transfer of this Agreement and/or substantially all of the assets of the Franchised Business, as well as to a proposed transfer, alone or together with other previous, simultaneous or proposed transfers, of any direct or indirect equity ownership interest in Franchisee that would result in a change of control of Franchisee or the Franchised Business ("Change of Control"). Unless waived by Franchisor, the conditions are:
  • 15.2.1 Franchisee and the Owners are required to be in compliance with all obligations to us under this Agreement and any other agreement with us and our affiliates as of the date of the request for our approval of the transfer, or make arrangements satisfactory to us to come into compliance by the date of the transfer.

15.2.2 The proposed transferee is required to:

  • (a) Demonstrate to our satisfaction that the proposed transferee and its owners and managers meet all of our then-current qualifications to become a franchisee of the Brand, which may include educational, managerial, and business standards; absence of involvement with Competing Businesses; good moral character, business reputation, and credit rating; and aptitude and ability to operate the Franchised Business. If the proposed transferee is already a franchisee of the Brand, that fact does not guarantee approval to become the operator of the Franchised Business. We have no less discretion with respect to a proposed transferee than we have with granting a new franchise.

  • (b) At our option, sign our then-current standard form of Franchise Agreement (or the standard form most recently offered to new franchisees) and related documents. The new Franchise Agreement may include new or increased fees and may otherwise differ, without limitation, from the terms of this Agreement.

  • (c) Require all owners of a beneficial interest in the transferee to sign our then-current form of Personal Guarantee and our other then-current standard documents.

    • (d) Successfully complete our then-current training requirements.
  • (e) Make arrangements to modernize and upgrade the Franchised Business, at the transferee's expense, to comply with our then-current Brand Standards.

  • (f) If the proposed transferee is another franchisee of the Brand, the proposed transferee is required to not have any outstanding notice of default under any agreements with us, have a good record of customer service and compliance with Brand Standards, and sign a general release in a form acceptable to us.

  • 15.2.3 Franchisee is required to pay us a transfer fee of $10,000 ("Transfer Fee"). If the proposed transferee was referred to you or us by a third-party (e.g., a broker) with whom we have a referral arrangement, then you or the proposed transferee, as a condition of approval, must pay us an additional fee equal to the amount owed under that referral arrangement. If we identify the prospective purchaser, then in addition to the Transfer Fee, we must receive the greater of: (a) $15,000; (b) three percent (3%) of the total purchase price; or (c) our actual costs to identify the prospective purchaser. Any amounts paid pursuant to this Section are nonrefundable.

  • 15.2.4 Franchisee and all Owners are required to sign a general release, in a form satisfactory to us, of all claims against us and our past, present and future affiliates, officers, directors, shareholders, agents and employees.

Source: Item 23 — RECEIPTS (FDD pages 88–312)

What This Means (2025 FDD)

According to Benjamin Franklin Plumbing's 2025 Franchise Disclosure Document, several conditions apply to the transfer of a franchise agreement. Benjamin Franklin Plumbing must give prior written consent for any transfer of interest in the agreement, the assets of the franchised business, or the equity ownership of the franchisee. This requirement extends to transfers occurring through various mechanisms, including family financial planning, estate planning, transfer to a trust, corporate reorganization, issuance or offering of securities, employee ownership plans, divorce, new marriage, bankruptcy, or receivership. The franchisee must notify Benjamin Franklin Plumbing in writing of any proposed transfer, provide all requested information, and refrain from completing the transfer until all requirements are met. If Benjamin Franklin Plumbing does not respond within 60 days after receiving all requested information, consent is considered refused.

Specifically, the franchisee and owners must comply with all obligations to Benjamin Franklin Plumbing under the franchise agreement and any other agreements with Benjamin Franklin Plumbing and its affiliates as of the date of the transfer request, or make satisfactory arrangements to come into compliance by the transfer date. The proposed transferee must meet all of Benjamin Franklin Plumbing's current qualifications for new franchisees, which may include educational, managerial, and business standards, absence of involvement with competing businesses, good moral character, business reputation, and credit rating, and aptitude and ability to operate the franchised business. Benjamin Franklin Plumbing has the right to communicate with and counsel the franchisee, the owners, and the proposed transferee on any aspect of a proposed transfer.

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing's option, the transferee may be required to sign the then-current standard form of franchise agreement and related documents, which may include new or increased fees and may otherwise differ from the original agreement. All owners of a beneficial interest in the transferee must sign Benjamin Franklin Plumbing's current form of personal guarantee and other standard documents. The transferee must also successfully complete Benjamin Franklin Plumbing's current training requirements and make arrangements to modernize and upgrade the franchised business to comply with current brand standards at their own expense. The franchisee is required to pay a transfer fee of $10,000. If Benjamin Franklin Plumbing identifies the prospective purchaser, they must receive the greater of $15,000, 3% of the total purchase price, or their actual costs to identify the purchaser, in addition to the transfer fee.

Furthermore, the franchisee and all owners must sign a general release of all claims against Benjamin Franklin Plumbing and its affiliates. They will remain liable for all obligations arising before the transfer date. The price and terms of the transfer must not negatively impact the future viability of the franchised business, in Benjamin Franklin Plumbing's judgment, and any financing incurred must be expressly subordinated to the transferee's obligations to Benjamin Franklin Plumbing. Any transfer not in compliance with these requirements is considered a material breach of the agreement, potentially leading to termination without an opportunity to cure.

Disclaimer: This information is extracted from the 2025 Franchise Disclosure Document and is provided for research purposes only. It does not constitute legal or financial advice. Consult with a franchise attorney before making any investment decisions.