Does the Cinch I.T. franchise agreement contain restrictions on the transfer of securities?
Cinch_I_T Franchise · 2024 FDDAnswer from 2024 FDD Document
| O | CERTAIN | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RESTRICTIONS CONTAINED IN A FRANCHISE AGREEMENT BETWEEN | |||||||
| CINCH FRANCHISE, LLC AND DATED | |||||||
| , 20" |
A stop transfer order shall be in effect against the transfer of any securities on Your records except transfers permitted by this Agreement.
(c) You acknowledge and agree that the restrictions on transfer imposed herein are reasonable and are necessary to protect Our franchise system; CINCH I.T. trade secrets and operating procedures; CINCH I.T.'s general high reputation and image; the Licensed Rights; as well as You and other CINCH I.T. franchisees. Any assignment or transfer permitted by this Agreement shall not be effective until We receive a completely executed copy of all transfer documents and consent
to such transfer in writing. Under no circumstances will You have a right to transfer under this Agreement before the Franchised Business has commenced operations.
- (d) Your performance is of vital importance to the market position and Our overall image, and there are many subjective factors that comprise the process by which We select a suitable franchisee. Our consent to a transfer or assignment by You of the Franchise and Franchised Business shall, in addition to the other restrictions and requirements herein noted, remain a subjective determination and shall consider, but not be limited to, whether:
- (i) All obligations of Yours under this Agreement and all other franchise documents, and the relationship created under those agreements are being assumed by the transferee;
- (ii) All ascertained debts of Yours to Us and Our affiliates have been paid;
- (iii) You, at the time of the request to transfer and as of the date of transfer, are not in default under this Agreement or any other franchise agreement;
- (iv) Except for other CINCH I.T. franchisees, the proposed transferee does not operate or participate in an entity that operates a franchise, license, or other business offering products and/or services similar to those offered by the Franchised Business;
- (v) The proposed transferee meets all of Our requirements for new franchisees, including, but not limited to, good reputation and character, experience, business acumen, operational ability, financial strength and stability, willingness and ability to devote the required time and best efforts to the operation of the Franchised Business and other business considerations as We may reasonably apply in evaluating new franchisees. You must provide Us all information We require concerning the proposed transaction (including a copy of the purchase agreement and all related documents), and about the proposed transferee;
- (vi) We shall have the right to approve the material terms and conditions of the transfer, including, without limitation, the right to confirm that the price and terms of payment are not so burdensome as to affect adversely the transferee's operation of the Franchised Business.
- (vii) The proposed transferee executes or, in appropriate circumstances, causes all necessary parties to execute Our then-current standard form of franchise agreement (provided that such execution will not serve to extend the then remaining term of the franchise) and such other then-current ancillary agreements being required by Us of new franchisees on the date of transfer;
- (viii) You, except to the extent prohibited by state law, have executed a general release of any and all claims against Us and Our subsidiaries and affiliates, and Our respective officers, managers, directors, agents and employees;
- (ix) You or proposed transferee have paid to Us a non-refundable Transfer Fee of Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000.00) to cover Our reasonable costs in effecting the transfer and other initial assistance to transferee;
- (x) The proposed transferee has paid to Us Our then-current non-refundable Initial Training Fee to attend the new franchisee Initial Training Program;
- (xi) If You are providing financing to the proposed transferee for any part of the purchase price, You have agreed that all of the proposed transferee's obligations under promissory notes, agreements or security interests reserved in the Franchised Business are subordinate to the proposed transferee's obligation to pay fees and other amounts due to Us and otherwise to comply with the Franchise Agreement;
Source: Item 23 — RECEIPTS (FDD pages 60–269)
What This Means (2024 FDD)
According to the 2024 Cinch I.T. Franchise Disclosure Document, the franchise agreement does place restrictions on the transfer of securities. A stop transfer order will be in effect against the transfer of any securities on the franchisee's records, except for transfers permitted by the agreement. Cinch I.T. requires this to protect its franchise system, trade secrets, operating procedures, reputation, image, and the rights of Cinch I.T. and its franchisees. Any permitted transfer is not effective until Cinch I.T. receives a fully executed copy of all transfer documents and consents to the transfer in writing, and no transfer is allowed before the franchised business commences operations.
Cinch I.T. also emphasizes that the franchisee's performance is vital to the company's market position and overall image, and the selection of a suitable franchisee involves many subjective factors. Cinch I.T.'s consent to a transfer or assignment of the franchise and franchised business is a subjective determination, considering factors such as whether the transferee assumes all obligations, all debts to Cinch I.T. and its affiliates have been paid, and the franchisee is not in default under any agreement. The proposed transferee cannot operate a similar business (with exceptions for other Cinch I.T. franchisees) and must meet all requirements for new franchisees, including reputation, character, experience, business acumen, operational ability, and financial strength.
Furthermore, if a franchisee, its principals, or affiliates decide to sell or transfer any ownership interest, Cinch I.T. has a right of first refusal to acquire the rights under the agreement or the ownership interest at the price and terms offered by the prospective buyer. The franchisor has 30 days to exercise this option. If Cinch I.T. does not exercise its right of first refusal, the franchisee may complete the sale, subject to Cinch I.T.'s approval of the buyer and other conditions. If the sale is not completed within 90 days, Cinch I.T. regains the right of first refusal. Additionally, any public offering of shares in a partnership or corporation with an ownership interest in the Multi-Unit Developer is subject to Cinch I.T.'s approval, which will not be unreasonably withheld.
These restrictions are typical in franchising to ensure the continued quality and consistency of the brand. Prospective Cinch I.T. franchisees should carefully review these transfer conditions and understand the implications for their exit strategy or any potential changes in ownership structure. The transfer process involves fees, specifically $5,000 for each unopened Cinch I.T. Franchised Business and $10,000 for each open and operating business, to cover administrative and other expenses related to the transfer.