What are the potential consequences of the pending litigation (Item 3) for the Checkersrallys brand and its trademarks (Item 13)?
Checkersrallys Franchise · 2025 FDDAnswer from 2025 FDD Document
on No. 4,475,419 | January 28, 2014 | | FOOD | | | All required affidavits of use and renewals have been filed.
Status of Principal Marks
There are no currently effective material determinations of the PTO, the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, the trademark administrator of any state or any court, nor are there any pending infringement, opposition or cancellation proceedings or material litigation, involving these Marks. There are no agreements currently in effect that significantly limit our right to use or license the use of these Marks in a manner material to the franchise.
From time to time, we become aware of other users of names, marks and/or restaurant building designs that may be confusingly similar to our Marks or our distinctive building design. Where appropriate, we will take legal action. Otherwise, there are no infringing uses actually known to us that could materially affect your use of these Marks.
Franchise Agreement
The Franchise Agreement grants you the right to use the Marks. If we believe, in our sole discretion, that it is advisable for us or you to modify or discontinue use of any Mark or use one or more additional or substitute trademarks, service marks or trade dress, you must comply with our directions. We will have no liability or obligation for your modification or discontinuance of any Mark or promotion of a substitute trademark, service mark or trade dress.
You must immediately notify us of any apparent infringement of or challenge to your use of any Mark, or claim by any person of any rights to any Mark and you must not communicate with any person other than us and our counsel in connection with any infringement, challenge or claim. We will have sole discretion to take any action we deem appropriate and will have the right to control exclusively any litigation or PTO or other administrative proceeding arising out of any infringement, challenge or claim or otherwise relating to any Mark. You must execute any and all instruments and documents, provide assistance and do such acts and things as, in the opinion of our counsel, may be necessary or advisable to protect our interests in any litigation or PTO or other administrative proceeding or otherwise to protect our interests in the Marks.
We will indemnify you against, and reimburse you for, all damages for which you are held liable in any proceeding arising out of your authorized use of any Mark under the
Franchise Agreement and, except as provided in the Franchise Agreement, for all costs you reasonably incur in defending any claim brought against you or any proceeding in which you are named as a party, if you have timely notified us of such claim or proceeding and you and your owners are in compliance with the Franchise Agreement and all other agreements entered into with us and our affiliates. At our sole discretion, we will be entitled to prosecute, defend or settle any proceeding arising out of your use of any Mark, and, if we decide to prosecute, defend or settle any such matter, we will have no obligation to indemnify or reimburse you for any fees or disbursements of counsel retained by you.
Development Agreement
The Development Agreement does not grant you the right to use any of the Marks. Your right to use the Marks is derived solely from the franchise agreements you enter into with us. You may not use any Mark as part of a corporate or legal business name or in any other manner not explicitly authorized in writing by us.
ITEM 14 PATENTS, COPYRIGHTS, AND PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
There are no patents or pending patent applications that are material to the franchise. We claim copyright protection for the Operations Manual and printed advertising and promotional materials. We have not registered the materials to which we claim copyright protection.
We consider certain information relating to the development and operations of Restaurants to be our trade secrets and proprietary information. This information includes:
- (i) ingredients, recipes and methods of preparation and presentation of certain food products;
- (ii) site selection criteria for Restaurants and plans and specifications for the development of Restaurants;
- (iii) sales, marketing and advertising programs and techniques for Restaurants;
- (iv) identity of suppliers and knowledge of specifications and pricing for authorized food products, materials, supplies and equipment;
- (v) knowledge of operating results and financial performance of Restaurants, other than your Franchised Restaurant;
- (vi) methods of inventory control, storage, product handling and management of Restaurants;
What This Means (2025 FDD)
According to the 2025 FDD, Checkersrallys faces potential consequences related to pending litigation, although the FDD states that there are no currently effective material determinations of the PTO, the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, the trademark administrator of any state or any court, nor are there any pending infringement, opposition or cancellation proceedings or material litigation, involving these Marks. Item 3 of the FDD mentions a pending litigation case, Checkers Drive-In Restaurants, Inc., v. Baby Buford, LLC, et. al., involving former Checkersrallys franchisees (Baby Buford, LLC, et al.) who had their franchise agreements terminated for failure to pay required advertising contributions. Baby Buford filed a Demand for Arbitration against Checkersrallys seeking $299,999 in damages, alleging wrongful termination and misappropriation of advertising contributions. Checkersrallys denies any wrongdoing. The court initially ordered separate arbitrations for each franchise entity, but the claimants have taken no further action since January 6, 2021, although the arbitration action has not been withdrawn. This could potentially lead to financial strain and legal expenses for Checkersrallys if the case is pursued further. However, the franchisees have not taken action since 2021.
Additionally, Item 3 mentions another pending litigation, Southern Shoals, LLC v. 2-32C Wheeler Road, Inc. et al., where Checkersrallys was initially incorrectly named as a defendant but subsequently filed a cross claim seeking indemnification from the franchisee. This could lead to legal expenses for Checkersrallys.
Item 13 states that Checkersrallys will take legal action where appropriate if they become aware of other users of names, marks, and/or restaurant building designs that may be confusingly similar to their Marks or their distinctive building design. The Franchise Agreement grants the franchisee the right to use the Marks. If Checkersrallys believes it is advisable to modify or discontinue use of any Mark or use one or more additional or substitute trademarks, service marks or trade dress, the franchisee must comply with Checkersrallys' directions. Checkersrallys will have no liability or obligation for the franchisee's modification or discontinuance of any Mark or promotion of a substitute trademark, service mark or trade dress. The franchisee must immediately notify Checkersrallys of any apparent infringement of or challenge to their use of any Mark, or claim by any person of any rights to any Mark. Checkersrallys will have sole discretion to take any action they deem appropriate and will have the right to control exclusively any litigation or PTO or other administrative proceeding arising out of any infringement, challenge or claim or otherwise relating to any Mark. Checkersrallys will indemnify the franchisee against, and reimburse them for, all damages for which they are held liable in any proceeding arising out of their authorized use of any Mark under the Franchise Agreement.