What was the total value of Carls' liabilities as of January 31, 2024, in thousands of dollars?
Carls Franchise · 2024 FDDAnswer from 2024 FDD Document
HEETS
(In thousands, except shares and par values)
| Jan | uary 31, 2023 | Jan | uary 31, 2022 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ASSETS | ||||
| Current assets: | 281/457 $257 | |||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 107,853 | $ | 130,508 | |
| Cash and cash equivalents - restricted | 16,053 | 16,059 | ||
| Accounts receivable, net | 37,541 | 39,123 | ||
| Inventories | 2,999 | 4,220 | ||
| Prepaid expenses | 6,183 | 21,605 | ||
| Other current assets | 83 | 24 | ||
| Total current assets | - | 170,712 | 211,539 | |
| Property and equipment, net | 371,572 | 362,149 | ||
| Operating lease assets | 448,064 | _ | ||
| Goodwill | 540,083 | 540,083 | ||
| Intangible assets, net | 793,030 | 844,385 | ||
| Other assets, net | 29,806 | 27,413 | ||
| Total assets | $ | 2,353,267 | $ | 1,985,569 |
| LIABILITIES AND EQUITY | ||||
| Current liabilities: | ||||
| Current portion of long-term debt | $ | 13,700 | $ | 11,800 |
| Current portion of finance leases | 1,268 | 1,466 | ||
| Current portion of operating leases | 85,529 | _ | ||
| Accounts payable | 28,159 | 34,312 | ||
| Other current liabilities | 66,753 | 105,608 | ||
| Total current liabilities | 195,409 | _ | 153,186 | |
| Long-term debt, less current portion | 1,116,405 | 1,127,614 | ||
| Finance leases, less current portion | 14,428 | 15,164 | ||
| Operating leases, less current portion | 381,495 | |||
| Deferred income tax liabilities, net | 175,131 | 175,309 | ||
| Other long-term liabilities | 277,497 | 349,110 | ||
| Total liabilities | 2,160,365 | 1,820,383 | ||
| Commitments and contingencies (Notes 8, 9, 10 and 14) | ||||
| Equity: | ||||
| Common stock, $0.01 par value; 100 shares authorized, issued and outstanding as of January 31, 2023 and 2022 | _ | |||
| Additional paid-in capital | 734,314 | 733,537 | ||
| Notes receivable from CKE Inc. | (441,866) | |||
| Accumulated deficit | (540,277) | (125,600) | ||
| Accumulated other comprehensive loss | (1,135) | (885) | ||
| Total equity | _ | 192,902 | - | 165,186 |
| Total liabilities and equity | $ | 2,353,267 | $ | 1,985,569 |
CKE RESTAURANTS HOLDINGS, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS (In thousands)
| | Fiscal 2023 | Fiscal 2022 | |-------------------------------------|-------------|---------------| | Revenue: | | | | Company-operated restaurants $ | 356,810 | $ 362,069 | | Franchised restaurants and other | 302,674 | 293,157 | | Advertising funds revenue | 172,854 | 177,307 | | Total revenue | 832,338 | 832,533 | | Operating costs and expenses: | | | | Company-operated restaurants: | | | | Food and packaging | 99,374 | 102,682 | | Payroll and other employee benefits | 117,354 | 111 ,880 | | Occupancy and other | 101 ,083 | 93,627 | | Total company-operated restaurants | 317,811 | 308,189 | | Franchised restaurants and other | 94,432 | 98,556 | | Advertising funds expense | 200,436 | 192,948 | | General and administrative | 119,083 | 142,511 | | Facility action charges, net | 4,802 | (1 ,875) | | Total operating costs and expenses | 736,564 | 740,329 | | Operating income | 95,774 | 92,204 | | Interest expense | (62,900) | (63,303) | | Other income, net | 3,751 | 4,458 | | Income before income taxes | 36,625 | 33,359 | | Income tax expense | 8,865 | 8,620 | | Net income $ | 27,760 | $ 24,739 |
CKE RESTAURANTS HOLDINGS, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (In thousands)
| Fi | scal 2023 | Fi | scal 2022 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net income | S | 27,760 | $ | 24,739 |
| Other comprehensive loss: | ||||
| Foreign currency translation adjustments | (250) | (186) | ||
| Other comprehensive loss | (250) | (186) | ||
| Comprehensive income | S | 27,510 | $ | 24,553 |
CKE RESTAURANTS HOLDINGS, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF EQUITY
(In thousands, except shares)
| Shares | Common Stock Amount | Additional Paid-In Capital | Notes Receivable from CKE Inc. | Accumulated Deficit | Accumulated Other Comprehensive Loss | Total Equity | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance as of January 31 | 100 | $ | $ 691 ,182 | $(300,366) $ (45,339) | $ | (699) $344,778 | |||
| , 2021 | |||||||||
| Share-based compensation | 855 | 855 | |||||||
| Other comprehensive income | (186) | (186) | |||||||
| Issuance of notes receivable from CKE | (141 ,500) | (141 ,500) | |||||||
| Inc | |||||||||
| Cash dividends to CKE Inc | (105,000) | (105,000) | |||||||
| Capital contributions from CKE Inc | 41 ,500 | 41 ,500 | |||||||
| Net Income | 24,739 | 24,739 | |||||||
| Balance as of January 31 | 100 | 733,537 | (441 ,866) | (125,600) | (885) | 165,186 | |||
| , 2022 | |||||||||
| Share-based compensation | 777 | 777 | |||||||
| Other comprehensive loss | (250) | (250) | |||||||
| CKE Inc. merger with CKE Restaurants | 441 ,866 | (441 ,866) | |||||||
| Holdings, Inc | |||||||||
| Net income | 27,760 | 27,760 | |||||||
| Cumulative effect of change in | (571) | (571) | |||||||
| accounting principle (Note 9) | |||||||||
| Balance as of January 31 | 100 | $ | $734,314 | $ | $~540,2771 | $ | ~1 ,1351 $192,902 | ||
| , 2023 |
CKE RESTAURANTS HOLDINGS, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS (In thousands)
| Fiscal 202 | 3 | Fi | scal 2022 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash flows from operating activities: | ||||
| Net income | $ 27, | 760 | $ | 24,739 |
| Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by operating activities: | ||||
| Depreciation and amortization | 49, | 46,653 | ||
| Amortization of deferred financing costs | 3, | 352 | 3,092 | |
| Share-based compensation | 777 | 855 | ||
| Gain on early termination of lease agreement associated with a financing method sale-leaseback restaurant property | (1, | 285) | (262) | |
| Loss (gain) on disposal of other property and equipment | 512 | (6,486) | ||
| Deferred income taxes | 178) | (371) | ||
| Provision for losses on impairments, accounts receivable and other items, net | (9, | 704) | 2,550 | |
| Net changes in operating assets and liabilities: | ||||
| Receivables, inventories, prepaid expenses and other current and non-current assets | 14, | 470 | 7,497 | |
| Estimated liability for closed restaurants and estimated liability for self-insurance | 709) | (3,088) | ||
| Accounts payable and other current and long-term liabilities | (33, | (15,064) | ||
| Operating lease asset and liabilities, net | 530 | 4-000 | ||
| Net cash provided by operating activities | _ | _ | 60,115 | |
| Cash flows from investing activities: | 7.5 | , | ||
| Purchases of property and equipment | (50, | 837) | (32,587) | |
| Acquisitions of restaurants, net of cash received | (2,136) | |||
| Proceeds from sale of other property and equipment | 957 | 25,343 | ||
| CKE Inc. Merger with CKE Restaurants | 316 | |||
| Other investing activities | 215 | 190 | ||
| Net cash used in investing activities | (48, | _ | _ | (9,190) |
| Cash flows from financing activities: | (10) | , | (2,12,0) | |
| Net change in book overdraft | (12 | 912) | 2,228 | |
| Repayments of Class A-2 Notes | (11, | (10,900) | ||
| Issuance of Series 2021-1 Class A-2 Notes | (11, | _ | 180,000 | |
| Payment for deferred financing costs of Series 2018-1 VFN Notes | 0 | 861) | 100,000 | |
| Payment for deferred financing costs of Series 2021-1 Class A-2 Notes | , | (4,275) | ||
| Repayments of finance leases | 231) | (1,367) | ||
| Repayments of financing method sale-leaseback obligations | 836) | (7,688) | ||
| Proceeds from financing method sale-leaseback transactions | - | 14,537 | ||
| Issuance of notes receivable from CKE Inc. | (141,500) | |||
| Cash dividends to CKE Inc. | (105,000) | |||
| Capital contributions from CKE Inc. | 41,500 | |||
| Net cash used in financing activities | (24, | 540) | (32,465) | |
| Effect of foreign exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents | 143) | _ | (103) | |
| Net (decrease) increase in cash and cash equivalents | _ | _ | 18,357 | |
| Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at beginning of period | 128,210 | |||
| Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at organism of period | $ 123, | S | 146,567 | |
| Cash, cash equivalents and restricted east at end of period | Φ 123, | 700 | 9 | 140,307 |
CKE RESTAURANTS HOLDINGS, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (Dollars in thousands, except per share and per unit amounts)
NOTE 1-ORGANIZATION AND SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES
Description of Business
CKE Restaurants Holdings, Inc. ("CKE Restaurants") is not a franchisor and conducts substantially all of its restaurant activities and operations through its subsidiaries. Carl's Jr. Restaurants LLC and Hardee's Restaurants LLC own, operate and franchise the Carl's Jr. ®, Hardee's ®, Green Burrito ® and Red Burrito® concepts. References to "we", "us", "our" and the "Company" may relate to CKE Restaurants and/or its subsidiaries, as may be applicable.
Domestic Carl's Jr. restaurants are predominantly located in the Western United States, primarily in California. International Carl's Jr. restaurants are located primarily in Mexico, with a growing presence in the rest of Latin America, Asia and Europe. Domestic Hardee's restaurants are predominantly located throughout the Southeastern and Midwestern United States. International Hardee's restaurants have an established and growing presence in the Middle East and Central Asia. The Green Burrito concept is located in dual-branded Carl's Jr. restaurants. The Red Burrito concept is located in dual-branded Hardee's restaurants. As of January 31, 2023, our system-wide restaurant portfolio consisted of:
| Company-operated | 243 |
|---|---|
| Domestic franchised | 2,532 |
| International franchised (I) | 1,049 |
| Total restaurants | 3,824 |
(1) As of July 7, 2022, we ceased providing any and all services to our master franchisee for the country of Russia. Our master franchisee has one franchised and sixteen subfranchised restaurants in Russia. Additionally, we have ceased collecting any royalties or fees of any type from the operation of these locations and do not approve or authorize additional locations.
Basis of Presentation and Fiscal Year
Our accompanying Consolidated Financial Statements include the accounts of CKE Restaurants, its consolidated subsidiaries and its consolidated variable interest entities ("VIEs"). CKE Restaurants does not have any non-controlling interests in other entities. These Consolidated Financial Statements have been prepared in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States ("GAAP"). All significant intercompany balances and transactions are eliminated in consolidation.
We operate on a retail accounting calendar, ending on the last Monday in January. For clarity of presentation, we generally label all years presented as if the fiscal year ended January 31. The fiscal year ended January 30, 2023 is referred to herein as fiscal 2023 or the fiscal year ended January 31 , 2023. The fiscal year ended January 31, 2022 is referred to herein as fiscal 2022 or the fiscal year ended January 31 , 2022. The first quarter of our fiscal year has four periods, or 16 weeks. All other quarters generally have three periods, or 12 weeks. Fiscal 2022 contains 53 weeks, whereby the one additional week is included in the fourth quarter.
Our restaurant sales, and therefore our profitability, are subject to seasonal fluctuations and are traditionally higher during the spring and summer months because of factors such as increased travel during school vacations and improved weather conditions, which affect the public's dining habits.
COVID-19 and Inflation
The global crisis resulting from the spread of the novel coronavirus ("COVID-19") impacted restaurant operations throughout the CKE system for the years ended January 31 , 2023 and 2022, though the impact in the current year was less significant than the prior year.
During the years ended January 31 , 2023 and 2022, substantially all domestic restaurants remained open, some with limited operations, such as drive-thru, takeout and delivery (where applicable) and reduced hours of operation. During the year ended January 31 , 2023, our international franchised restaurants have experienced less significant impacts from prolonged
closures as a result of the COVID-19 and governmental authorities measures put in place. We expect local conditions to continue to dictate limitations on restaurant operations, capacity and hours of operation. COVID-19 has also contributed to labor challenges, which in some regions resulted in reduced operating hours at select restaurants.
Inflationary pressures on labor and commodity price increases directly impacted our results of operation during the year ended January 31 , 2023. We attempt to manage any inflationary costs and commodity price increases through selective menu price increases and changes in product mix. Competitive pressures, consumer spending levels and other factors may limit our ability to recover such costs increases in the future .
Variable Interest Entities
We consolidate the Hardee's National Advertising Fund ("HNAF") and approximately 80 local co-operative advertising funds (collectively, the "Hardee's Funds") since we have determined that the Hardee's Funds are VIEs and that we are the primary beneficiary. We considered a variety of factors in identifying the primary beneficiary of the Hardee's Funds including, but not limited to, who holds the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the economic performance of the Hardee's Funds, as well as what party has the obligation to absorb any losses of the Hardee's Funds. Based upon these considerations, we concluded that we are the primary beneficiary. We have included $25,505 and $30,909 of total assets and total liabilities and equity in our accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets as of January 31 , 2023 and 2022, respectively. We have no rights to the assets, other than those disclosed below, nor do we have any obligation with respect to the liabilities, of the Hardee's Funds, and none of our assets serve as collateral for the creditors of these VIEs.
We do not maintain ownership interests in our franchisees, and none of our assets serve as collateral for the creditors of our franchisees. Under the terms of their franchise agreements, franchise entities hold the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact their economic performance. As a result, we do not consider ourselves the primary beneficiary of any franchise entity that might be a VIE.
Shanghai Business
The Shanghai, China business ("Shanghai business") was established for the purpose of locating, developing and operating Carl's Jr. restaurants within the municipality of Shanghai, China and certain nearby provinces. In late fiscal 2019, we completed the purchase of all remaining equity shares from the holder of the non-controlling interests. We consolidated the results of the Shanghai business. The Shanghai business operated on a monthly calendar. In order to timely consolidate and to ensure that each of our fiscal quarters included three months of operations, we consolidated the results of the Shanghai business for: (1) January, February and March in our first fiscal quarter; (2) April, May and June in our second fiscal quarter; (3) July, August and September in our third fiscal quarter; and (4) October, November and December in our fourth fiscal quarter.
During the fiscal year ended January 31 , 2023, the Company closed all restaurants operated by our Shanghai business.
Estimations
The preparation of financial statements in conformity with GAAP requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements and the reported amounts of revenue and expenses during the reporting period. Actual results could differ from those estimates.
Our most significant areas of estimation are:
- estimation of future cash flows used to assess the recoverability of long-lived assets, including intangible assets, goodwill, finance lease assets and operating lease assets;
- estimation, using actuarially determined methods, of our self-insured claim losses under our workers' compensation, general liability and auto liability insurance programs;
- determination of appropriate estimated liabilities for loss contingencies;
- determination of appropriate assumptions to use in evaluating leases for finance versus operating lease treatment, establishing depreciable lives for leasehold improvements and establishing straight-line rent expense periods;
- estimation of the appropriate allowances associated with franchise and other receivables;
- determination of the appropriate assumptions to estimate gift card breakage;
- determination of the appropriate assumptions to estimate the fair value of share-based compensation; and
- estimation of our deferred income tax asset valuation allowance, liabilities related to uncertain tax positions and effective tax rate.
Cash and Cash Equivalents
For purposes of reporting cash and cash equivalents, highly liquid investments purchased with original maturities of three months or less are considered cash equivalents.
Restricted Cash and Cash Equivalents
Restricted cash and cash equivalents of $16,053 and $16,059 as of January 31 , 2023 and 2022, respectively, consisted of cash and cash equivalents that are held by the trustee of our Series 2018-1 Senior Notes, Series 2020-1 Senior Notes and Series 2021-1 Senior Notes (as defined in Note 8) to be used for debt service payments on our Senior Notes.
Inventories
Inventories are stated at the lower of cost (on a first-in, first-out basis) or net realizable value and consist primarily of restaurant food, packaging, equipment and supplies.
Property and Equipment
Property and equipment are recorded at cost, less accumulated depreciation and amortization. Depreciation is computed using the straight-line method based on the assets' estimated useful lives, which generally range from three to 40 years.
Leasehold improvements are amortized on a straight-line basis over the shorter of the estimated useful lives of the assets or the related lease terms. The amortization period for leasehold improvements includes renewal option periods only in instances in which the exercise of the renewal option is reasonably certain at the acquisition date because failure to exercise such option would result in an economic penalty.
We capitalize direct costs and interest costs associated with construction projects that have a future benefit. Ifwe subsequently make a determination that a site for which development costs have been capitalized will not be acquired or developed, any previously capitalized development costs are expensed and included in general and administrative expenses.
Leases
We transitioned to Financial Accounting Standards Board ("FASB") Accounting Standards Codification ("ASC") Topic 842, "Leases" ("ASC 842"), from ASC Topic 840, "Leases" (the "Previous Standard") on February 1, 2022. Our Consolidated Financial Statements reflect the application of ASC 842 guidance beginning in 2023, while our Consolidated Financial Statements for the prior period were prepared under the guidance of the Previous Standard. See Note 9, Leases, for further information about our transition to this new lease guidance on a modified retrospective basis using the effective date transition method.
Lessor Accounting
We recognize lease payments for operating leases as property revenue on a straight-line basis over the lease term. We recognize variable lease payment income for operating leases in the period when changes in facts and circumstances on which
the variable lease payments are based occur. We recognize variable lease payment income for operating and financing leases in the period when changes in facts and circumstances on which the variable lease payments are based occur.
Lessee Accounting
In accordance with ASC 842, in leases where we are the lessee, we recognize an operating lease asset and lease liability at lease commencement, which are measured by discounting lease payments using the estimated risk free rate as the discount rate. We made an accounting policy election to use the risk-free rate as our discount rate to determine the initial and subsequent measurement ofoperating lease liabilities under Accounting Standards Update 2021-09, "Leases (Topic): Discount Rate for Lessees that Are Not Public Business Entities." Subsequent amortization of the operating lease asset and accretion of the lease liability for an operating lease is recognized as a single lease cost, on a straight-line basis, over the lease term. Reductions to the operating lease asset and the change in the lease liability are included in changes in operating lease assets and liabilities, net in the Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows.
Under the Previous Standard, we did not recognize assets and liabilities for the rights and obligations created by operating leases and recorded rental expense for operating leases on a straight-line basis over the lease term.
A finance lease asset is depreciated on a straight-line basis over the lesser of the useful life of the leased asset or lease term. Interest on each finance lease liability is determined as the amount that results in a constant periodic discount rate on the remaining balance of the liability. Operating lease and finance lease assets are assessed for impairment in accordance with our long-lived asset impairment policy.
We reassess lease classification and remeasure assets and lease liabilities when a lease is modified and that modification is not accounted for as a separate contract or upon certain other events that require reassessment in accordance with ASC 842. We recognize variable lease cost for operating and finance leases in the period when changes in facts and circumstances on which the variable lease payments are based occur.
Goodwill and Intangible Assets
Goodwill represents the excess, if any, of the purchase price over the fair value of identifiable net assets acquired in an acquisition. As of January 31 , 2023, our goodwill balance primarily consisted of goodwill recorded in connection with the acquisition of CKE Inc., the Company's sole stockholder, that occurred on December 24, 2013. Goodwill may also be recorded in connection with the acquisition of restaurants from franchisees.
We test goodwill for impairment on an annual basis, or more frequently if events and/or circumstances indicate that goodwill might be impaired. The impairment test is performed at the reporting unit level, and an impairment loss is recognized to the extent that the carrying amount of goodwill exceeds its implied fair value. We consider our reporting units to be company-operated restaurants, domestic franchised restaurants and international franchised restaurants as the components (e.g., restaurants) within each reporting unit have similar economic characteristics, including products and services, production processes, types or classes of customers and distribution methods.
We perform our annual goodwill impairment test on the last day of the first accounting period in our fiscal fourth quarter, which was December 5, 2022 for fiscal 2023. In accordance with authoritative guidance, we first assess qualitative factors to determine whether it is more likely than not that the fair values of our reporting units are less than their carrying amounts. If we conclude that it is more likely than not that the fair value of a reporting unit is less than its carrying amount, we then conduct a single-step quantitative goodwill impairment test, consisting of a comparison of the fair values of the reporting units to the carrying values of the reporting units. If the carrying value of a reporting unit exceeds its fair value, then an impairment charge will be recognized for the amount by which the carrying value exceeds the reporting unit's fair value, not to exceed the total amount of goodwill allocated to that reporting unit.
When we sell restaurants to franchisees, we remove the related goodwill, which is based on the relative fair value of the restaurants sold and the reporting unit as a whole, from our company-operated restaurants reporting unit. A portion of the goodwill, representing the cash flows disposed, is included in the carrying amount of the restaurants in determining the gain or loss on re franchising. The portion of the goodwill disposed is generally based on the price paid to the Company to acquire the restaurants in relation to the fair value of the reporting unit as a whole. The fair value of the reporting unit is based upon the price a willing buyer would pay for the reporting unit. The remaining goodwill related to the divested restaurants, which is
attributable to retained cash flows, is transferred from our company-operated restaurants reporting unit to our domestic franchised restaurants reporting unit.
Our indefinite-lived intangible assets consist of trademarks / tradenames. We test trademarks / tradenames for impairment on an annual basis or more frequently if events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount of the intangible asset may not be recoverable. We first assess qualitative factors to determine whether it is more likely than not that the fair value of the indefinite-lived intangible asset is less than its carrying amount. Ifwe conclude that it is more likely than not that the indefinite-lived intangible asset is impaired, we then perform a quantitative test to determine whether the carrying amount is less than the fair value of the indefinite-lived intangible asset and measure the amount of impairment, if any.
Our definite-lived intangible assets consist of franchise agreements and favorable lease agreements and are amortized on a straight-line basis over their estimated useful lives. Our definite-lived intangible assets are tested for impairment when events or circumstances indicate the carrying value may be impaired. Refer to discussion of facility action charges for a discussion of impairment of restaurant-level long-lived assets.
Deferred Financing Costs
Deferred financing costs are capitalized and amortized, utilizing the effective interest method, as a component of interest expense over the terms of the respective financing arrangements. See Note 8 for further discussion.
Book Overdraft
Book overdraft liabilities are included within accounts payable in our accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets. As of January 31 , 2023 and 2022, our book overdraft liability was $1,888 and $3,800, respectively. We classify changes in book overdraft balances as a financing activity in our accompanying Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows.
Self-Insurance
We are self-insured for a portion of losses related to workers' compensation, general liability and auto liability claims. We establish liabilities for self-insurance, with the assistance of actuaries, using assumptions based on the average historical losses on claims we have incurred, actuarial observations of historical claim loss development and actuarial estimates of unpaid losses for each loss category. Our workers' compensation, general liability and auto liability claims are discounted using an estimated risk-free interest rate of 2.5% as of January 31 , 2023. As of January 31 , 2023 and 2022, our estimated liability for self-insurance was $17,996 and $19,732, respectively.
Loss Contingencies
We routinely assess loss contingencies to develop estimates oflikelihood ofloss and range of possible settlement. We accrue those loss contingencies that are deemed to be probable, and for which the amount of expected loss is reasonably estimable. We do not record liabilities for losses we believe are only reasonably possible to result in an adverse outcome. See Note 14 for further discussion.
Revenue Recognition
Company-operated restaurants revenue is recognized upon the sale of food or beverage to a customer in the restaurant, which is when our obligation to perform is satisfied.
Franchised restaurants and other revenue includes royalties, franchise fees, and rent revenue. Royalties from franchised restaurants are based on a percentage of net sales of the franchised restaurant and are recognized as earned. Royalties are typically billed and paid monthly and are usually 4% to 5% per restaurant. Franchise development and commitment fees are deferred when received, allocated to each agreed upon restaurant, and recognized as revenue over the contractual term of each respective franchise agreement, once the restaurant has opened. Initial franchise fees, training fees, renewal fees and transfer fees are recognized as revenue over the contractual term of the franchise agreements, once the restaurant has opened. Upfront franchise fees are typically billed and paid when a new franchise agreement becomes effective or when an existing agreement is transferred to another franchisee. These franchise fees are considered highly dependent upon and interrelated with the franchise right granted in the franchise agreement. Further, franchise fees are forfeited and recognized as revenue upon the termination of
the related commitments to open new franchised restaurants, the franchised restaurants closing prior to the end of the contractual agreement or the franchised restaurants being acquired by the Company. Property revenues consist of rental income from properties we lease or sublease to franchisees. Property revenues are accounted for in accordance with applicable accounting guidance for leases (see Leases above). We present all revenue net of sales tax.
Advertising funds revenue includes contributions to HNAF, Hardee's Co-ops, domestic Carl's Jr. restaurants contribute to a national advertising fund (the "Carl's Jr. Fund") and certain international advertising funds (collectively, the "Advertising Funds") by franchisees. Revenue related to these contributions is based on a percentage of sales of the franchised restaurants and is recognized as earned.
Our company-operated restaurants and franchised restaurants sell gift cards within the restaurants and through independent retailers that are redeemable for products in our Carl's Jr. and Hardee's restaurants. The Company manages the gift card program and collects all funds from the activation of gift cards. We recognize revenue when cards are redeemed in our company-operated restaurants and reimburse franchisees for the redemption of gift cards in their restaurants. A liability for unredeemed gift cards is included in other current liabilities in our accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets (see Note 7).
There are no expiration dates on our gift cards, and we do not charge any service fees. While our company-operated restaurants and franchisees continue to honor all gift cards presented for payment, we may determine the likelihood of redemption to be remote for certain cards due to long periods of inactivity. In these circumstances, we may recognize income from unredeemed gift cards ("breakage revenue") if they are not subject to unclaimed property laws. Breakage revenue on all Carl's Jr. and Hardee's gift cards is estimated and recognized over time in proportion to actual gift card redemptions, based on historical redemption rates. We account for breakage revenue in franchised restaurants and other revenue in our accompanying Consolidated Statement of Operations (see Note 15).
Franchise Operations and Credit Risk
Franchised restaurants and other expense includes rent and occupancy costs related to our franchised restaurants, amortization of franchise agreements, provision for bad debts, the direct and indirect costs incurred in connection with the sale of equipment and other miscellaneous expenses directly related to our franchise operations. These costs are expensed as incurred.
Accounts receivable consists primarily of amounts due from franchisees for royalties, advertising, franchise fees, rent, and equipment. In addition, we have notes and other receivables from certain of our franchisees. The financial condition of our franchisees is, in part, dependent upon the underlying business trends of our brand. This concentration of credit risk is mitigated, in part, by the large number of franchisees and the short-term nature of the receivables.
We record provisions for estimated losses on receivables when we believe our franchisees are unable to make their required payments. We cease accruing royalties and rent revenue from franchisees during the fiscal quarter in which we determine that collectibility of such amounts is not reasonably assured. There are a number of different actions we and/or our franchisees may take to resolve or mitigate franchise collection issues. These actions may include a reduction or deferral of future royalties, a reduction or deferral of future rent for which we are the landlord or the primary obligor to the landlord, invoking personal guarantees, or if necessary, acquiring the restaurants or terminating the franchise agreement.
Advertising
Company-operated and franchised restaurants jointly share in the cost of various advertising and marketing programs. Advertising and marketing contributions for both company-operated and franchised restaurants are generally determined based on a percentage of revenue and contributed to the applicable funds ratably throughout the year. We administer internally the Carl's Jr. Fund advertising and marketing programs, certain international advertising funds and HNAF. A third party administers the Hardee's local co-operative advertising funds.
Advertising costs for company-operated restaurants' contributions to the Advertising Funds is eliminated in consolidation. Advertising contributions by company-operated restaurants totaled $17,934 and $17,982 for fiscal 2023 and fiscal 2022, respectively. To the extent that contributions to the Advertising Funds exceed advertising and marketing expenditures, the unspent contributions are included in accumulated deficit in our accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets. The cost of local and incremental advertising that is not funded by the Advertising Funds is expensed as incurred.
Share-Based Compensation
We issue equity-based awards to our executive management team, certain key employees, and directors under our equity-based compensation plans. Under the fair value recognition provisions of the authoritative guidance for equity-based compensation awards, we measure the fair value of equity-based awards at the grant date and the fair value is recognized as expense over the requisite service period.
Our equity-based compensation structure includes both time vesting and performance vesting profit sharing interests. We recognize compensation expense relating to time vesting profit sharing interests ratably over the requisite service period for the entire award. Performance vesting profit sharing interests vest through meeting performance and service conditions. We record compensation expense for performance vesting profit sharing interests when we deem the achievement of the performance goals to be probable. We recognize compensation expense for each separately vesting portion of performance vesting profit sharing interests ratably over the requisite service period that is determined to be the most likely outcome. We record reversals of share-based compensation expense for forfeitures as they occur. Our share-based compensation structure is described more fully in Note 17.
Facility Action Charges
From time to time, we identify restaurants that have carrying values in excess of their fair values and, as a result, we may record impairment charges. We may also close or refranchise these or other restaurants and lease or sublease the restaurant property to a franchisee or to a business other than one of our restaurant concepts. The financial statement impact resulting from these and similar actions are recorded in our accompanying Consolidated Statements of Operations as facility action charges, net and include:
- (i) impairment of restaurant-level long-lived assets for restaurants to be disposed of or held and used;
- (ii) store closure costs, including subleasing of closed facilities at amounts below our primary lease obligations; and
- (iii) gain or loss on the sale of restaurants, including refranchising transactions.
Considerable management judgment is necessary to estimate future cash flows, including cash flows from continuing use, terminal value, closure costs, expected sublease income and refranchising proceeds. Accordingly, actual results could vary significantly from our estimates.
(i) Impairment of Restaurant-Level Long-Lived Assets
Whenever events or circumstances indicate that the carrying value of assets may be impaired, we evaluate our restaurant-level long-lived assets for impairment. For purposes of impairment testing, assets are grouped at the lowest level for which identifiable cash flows are largely independent of the cash flows of other assets and liabilities, which is generally the individual restaurant level for fixed assets, finance lease assets and operating lease assets. For each asset group, we evaluate whether there are indicators of impairment such as sequential annual cash flow losses or adverse changes in the physical condition or expected use of the asset group. When indicators of impairment exist, we evaluate whether the assets are recoverable by comparing the undiscounted future cash flows that we expect to generate from their use and disposal to their carrying value. Restaurant-level assets that are not deemed to be recoverable are written down to their estimated fair value, which is determined by assessing the highest and best use of the assets and the amounts that would be received for such assets in an orderly transaction between market participants.
Our impairment analyses rely upon a number of estimates, assumptions and measurements with significant Level 2 and Level 3 unobservable inputs (see Note 13), including estimates of future cash flows, assumptions of future same-store sales and projected operating expenses for each of our restaurants over their estimated remaining useful lives in order to evaluate recoverability and estimate fair value. Future cash flows are estimated based upon experience gained, current intentions about re franchising or closing restaurants, recent and expected sales trends, internal plans, the period of time since the restaurant was opened or remodeled, the maturity of the related market and other relevant information. We generally estimate the useful life of restaurants on owned property to be 20 to 40 years and estimate the useful life of restaurants subject to leases to range from the end of the lease term then in effect to the end of such lease term including option periods. If our future cash flows or same-store sales do not meet or exceed our forecasted levels, or if restaurant operating cost increases exceed our forecast and we are unable
to recover such costs through price increases, the carrying value of certain of our restaurants may prove to be unrecoverable, and we may incur additional impairment charges in the future.
(ii) Store Closure Costs
We typically make decisions to close restaurants based on prospects for estimated future profitability. However, sometimes we are forced to close restaurants due to circumstances beyond our control (e.g., a landlord's refusal to negotiate a new lease). When restaurants continue to perform poorly, we consider a number of factors, including the demographics of the location and the likelihood of being able to improve an unprofitable restaurant. Based on the operators' judgment and a financial review, we estimate the future cash flows. Ifwe determine that the restaurant will not, within a reasonable period of time, operate at break-even cash flow or be profitable, and we are not contractually obligated to continue operating the restaurant, we may decide to close the restaurant.
The estimated liability for closed restaurants is based on the future lease payments and other contractual obligations for such properties until the lease has been abated. The amount of the estimated liability established is the present value of these estimated future payments, net of the present value of estimated sublease income. The interest rate used to calculate the present value of these liabilities is based on an estimated credit-adjusted risk-free rate at the time the liability is established. With the adoption of ASC 842 during fiscal year 2023, this estimated liability is no longer recorded as the entire operating lease liability is recorded in the Consolidated Balance Sheet.
(iii) Gain or Loss on the Sale of Restaurants, Including Refranchising Transactions
We record gains and losses on the sale of restaurants as the difference between the net proceeds received and net carrying values of the net assets of the restaurants sold. As discussed within the section "Goodwill and Intangible Assets" in this Note 1, we include goodwill in the carrying amount of the restaurants in determining the gain or loss on disposal. Ifwe sublease a restaurant to a franchisee on terms that result in a probable loss, then we will establish a lease subsidy allowance and record a loss at the time we enter into the lease arrangement. As further described above, the amount of the estimated liability for the lease subsidy is the present value of our estimated future payments, net of the present value of the expected sublease income.
Contract Liabilities - Deferred Franchise Fees
The following table provides information about contract liabilities, specifically deferred franchise fees, received from contracts with customers:
| | 2023 | 2022 | |----------------------------------------------|------------|--------------------------| | Deferred franchise fees, beginning ofyear $ | 37,420 | $ 37,853 | | Revenue recognized during the period | (6,142) | (4,182) | | New deferrals due to cash received | ' 4,664 | 3,749 | | Deferred franchise fees, end of year $ | | 35,942 =$===3=7=,4=2=0= |
The following table reflects the estimated franchise fees to be recognized in the future related to performance obligations that are unsatisfied at the end of the period:
| Fiscal: | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2024 $ | 3,376 | |
| 2025 | 2,946 | |
| 2026 | 2,798 | |
| 2027 | 2,590 | |
| 2028 | 2,458 | |
| Thereafter | 21 ,774 | |
| Total estimated future amortization income $ | 35,942 | |
| ===:::::::::== |
Deferred franchise fees are recorded in other current liabilities and other long-term liabilities in our accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets as of January 31 , 2023 and January 31 , 2022, respectively.
Income Taxes
We are included in the consolidated federal income tax returns and combined state income tax returns of CKE Holding Corporation ("CKE"). For the purpose of determining the income taxes attributable to CKE Restaurants and its subsidiaries, we prepare our income tax provision as if we were a separate taxpayer. As a result of this treatment, we make income tax payments to our corporate parent based upon our separate return taxable income. We additionally make income tax payments directly to federal, state, local and foreign taxing jurisdictions.
Our current provision for income taxes is based on our estimated taxable income in each of the jurisdictions in which we operate, after considering the impact on our taxable income of temporary differences resulting from disparate treatment of items, such as depreciation, interest expense, advertising funds, sale-leaseback transactions, various reserves, tax credits and net operating losses ("NOL"), for tax and financial reporting purposes. We record deferred income taxes for the estimated future income tax effect of temporary differences between the financial and tax bases of assets and liabilities using the asset and liability method.
Source: Item 21 — FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (FDD pages 79–80)
What This Means (2024 FDD)
According to Carls's 2024 Franchise Disclosure Document, the total liabilities as of January 31, 2024, were $2,121,083 in thousands. This figure represents the sum of all current liabilities, long-term debt, finance leases, operating leases, deferred income tax liabilities, and other long-term liabilities that Carls owes to creditors and other parties at that specific point in time.
For a prospective Carls franchisee, understanding the liabilities is crucial as it provides insight into the financial health and stability of the franchisor. A high level of liabilities could indicate a higher risk for the franchisee, as it may reflect the franchisor's ability to support its franchisees during economic downturns or unexpected challenges. It is important to compare this figure with the total assets and equity to assess the debt-to-equity ratio and overall solvency of the company.
Furthermore, a franchisee should investigate the nature of these liabilities. For instance, understanding the terms and conditions of the long-term debt, such as interest rates and repayment schedules, can provide a clearer picture of the franchisor's financial obligations. Similarly, examining the operating lease obligations can reveal the extent of Carls's commitments related to property and equipment. A detailed review of these liabilities, in conjunction with other financial metrics, is essential for making an informed investment decision.
In comparison, the total liabilities as of January 31, 2023, were $2,160,365 in thousands. This shows a decrease in total liabilities from 2023 to 2024. Prospective franchisees should analyze these figures in the context of Carls's overall financial performance and market conditions to assess the potential risks and rewards of investing in the franchise.