What is the Beard Papas franchisor's obligation to prevent competition within a franchisee's designated territory?
Beard_Papas Franchise · 2025 FDDAnswer from 2025 FDD Document
ery services, deliver Approved Services and Products to customers located outside Franchisee's Designated Territory;
- (8) Franchisor, in Franchisor's Reasonable Business Judgment and for any reason or no reason at all, may prohibit Franchisee from soliciting customers located outside Franchisee's Designated Territory;
- (9) Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement including, but not limited to, the Reserved Rights, provided that, at all times Franchisee is and remains in compliance with all of the terms of this Agreement, during the Term of this Agreement, neither Franchisor nor any affiliate of Franchisor will establish or operate, or grant a franchise to any third party to establish or operate, a Shop using the Licensed Marks and System at a Shop Location that is located within Franchisee's Designated Territory (provided that a Designated Territory has been designated and approved by Franchisor in accordance with the terms of this Agreement) but excluding Closed Markets. Franchisee may face competition from other Beard Papa's Shops and other System franchisees with shop locations and/or designated territories, including Shops that are located within Closed Markets and/or located adjacent to and/or within a close proximity to Franchisee's Shop Location and/or Designated Territory. Franchisee agrees that although Franchisor may disapprove of any marketing medium that is distributed and/or reaches outside of Franchisee's Designated Territory, that Franchisor is not obligated to do so and that Franchisee may face competition from other Beard Papa's Shops and System franchisees that market and promote their Beard Papa's Shop through internet, mail, public relations, Third party Ordering and/or Delivery Services, and other marketing activities and mediums that are distributed to or within Franchisee's Designated Territory. Franchisee agrees that Franchisee shall not receive any compensation whatsoever if Franchisor or another System franchisee solicits customers from within Franchisee's Designated Territory; and
- (10) The foregoing rights granted in this Article 2.A. are subject to and contingent upon each and every, term and condition of this Agreement, the rights of any prior user, and are non-exclusive and subordinate to the Reserved Rights.
2.B. TERM
Unless sooner terminated pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, the term of this Agreement will be for a period of 10 consecutive years, commencing from the Effective Date (the "Term").
2.C. GUARANTEES, CONFIDENTIALITY AND RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS
If Franchisee is, at any time, a Corporate Entity, Franchisee agrees that each Owner and their respective Spouse shall execute, sign and deliver to Franchisor the Owner and Spouse Agreement and Guaranty attached to this Agreement as Exhibit 1 and, in doing so, among other things, will individually, jointly, and severally, guarantee Franchisee's obligations under this Agreement and personally bind themselves to confidentiality and non-competition covenants and restrictions.
2.D. RESERVATION OF RIGHTS
Franchisor on behalf of itself, its affiliates and its assigns retains all rights, on any and all terms and conditions that Franchisor deems advisable and without any compensation or consideration to Franchisee to engage in the following activities (the "Reserved Rights"): (a) operate and grant to others the right to operate a Franchised Business, Beard Papa's Shop and/or other shops using the System and Licensed Marks at locations outside Franchisee's Designated Territory; (b) acquire, develop, or merge with or otherwise affiliate with one or more businesses of any kind, including businesses that are Competitive Businesses, and after such acquisition, merger or affiliation to own and operate and to franchise or license others to own and operate and to continue to own and operate such businesses, including Competitive Businesses but, not using the Licensed Marks, within Franchisee's Designated Territory; (c) be acquired by, develop, or merge with or otherwise affiliate with one or more businesses of any kind, including businesses that are Competitive Businesses, even if such business or businesses presently or, in the future, own and operate and franchise or license others to own and operate such businesses, including Competitive Businesses but, not using the Licensed Marks, within Franchisee's Designated Territory; (d) use the Licensed Marks and System to distribute the Approved Services and Products or products and services similar to the Approved Services and Products in Alternative Channels of Distribution within or outside Franchisee's Designated Territory; (e) operate and grant to others the right to operate a Beard Papa's Shop at Captive Markets, both within and outside Franchisee's Designated Territory; and (f) use the Licensed Marks and System and to license others to use the Licensed Marks and System to engage in all other activities not expressly prohibited by this Agreement.
2.E. MODIFICATION OF SYSTEM
Franchisor, in Franchisor's Reasonable Business Judgment, reserves the right at all times to supplement, modify, alter and/or amend the System. Franchisee shall promptly comply with all such modifications to the System whether such modification(s) results in the addition, subtraction, modification and/or enhancement to any and/or all components of the System. Franchisor shall provide Franchisee with a reasonable time period to comply with any change or modification to the System which shall be communicated in writing by Franchisor to Franchisee, including, but not limited to, modifications, updated, amendments, and changes made by Franchisor to the Operations Manual. Franchisor's modifications to the System shall not materially alter Franchisee's fundamental rights under this Agreement.
2.F. CORPORATE ENTITY OWNERSHIP
If Franchisee is a Corporate Entity, Franchisee represents that the information contained in Schedule 2 to this Agreement is and shall remain complete, true and accurate throughout the Term of this Agreement.
ARTICLE 3 RESTAURANT LOCATION, DEVELOPMENT, AND OPERATIONS
3.A. RESTAURANT LOCATION
Franchisee shall develop, operate and manage the Franchised Business from a Shop Facility that is developed and established at a Shop Location, that: (a) was identified and evaluated by Franchisee; (b) complies with the terms and conditions of this Agreement; (c) satisfies and meets Franchisor's standards and specifications; (d) is timely presented by Franchisee to Franchisor for approval as Franchisee's proposed Shop Location; (e) is approved by Franchisor as Franchisee's Shop Location; (f) is timely secured by Franchisee within 120 days of the Effective Date of this Agreement, as evidenced by a binding lease with a duration equal to the full Term of this Agreement; (g) is and, at all times, shall be exclusively dedicated to the operation of the Franchised Business; (h) is located within the Designated Territory, if Franchisor previously designated and approved, in writing, a Designated Territory; and (i) otherwise meets the terms and conditions of this Agreement and Franchisor's standards and specifications.
Franchisee will not lease, purchase or otherwise acquire a proposed Shop Location until such information as Franchisor may require as to the proposed Shop Location has been provided to Franchisor by Franchisee and, Franchisor has approved the location in accordance with the terms and conditions of this Agreement including, but not limited to, Article 2.A. of this Agreement. Franchisor shall respond to Franchisee's request for approval of a proposed Shop Location within a reasonable time period but not exceeding 30 days following Franchisor's receipt, from Franchisee, of complete written information about Franchisee's proposed Shop Location.
Source: Item 23 — RECEIPTS (FDD pages 58–275)
What This Means (2025 FDD)
According to the 2025 Beard Papas Franchise Disclosure Document, Beard Papas, under specific conditions, agrees not to establish or operate, nor grant a franchise to a third party to establish or operate, a shop using the Licensed Marks and System within a franchisee's designated territory. This is applicable only if a designated territory has been properly designated and approved by Beard Papas and excludes Closed Markets. This obligation is valid for the term of the agreement, provided the franchisee remains in compliance with all agreement terms.
However, the FDD also states that franchisees may face competition from other Beard Papa's shops and other system franchisees, including those in Closed Markets or adjacent to the franchisee's location. Beard Papas is not obligated to disapprove of marketing mediums that extend outside a franchisee's designated territory, meaning franchisees may face competition from other shops marketing through the internet, mail, public relations, or third-party delivery services within their territory. Franchisees are not entitled to compensation if Beard Papas or another franchisee solicits customers from within their designated territory.
Beard Papas also retains significant rights, including the right to operate or franchise businesses outside the franchisee's designated territory, engage in or affiliate with competitive businesses (excluding the use of Licensed Marks within the franchisee's territory), use Licensed Marks in alternative distribution channels, and operate shops in Captive Markets, both within and outside the designated territory. These rights are subject to all terms and conditions of the agreement, the rights of any prior user, and are non-exclusive and subordinate to the Reserved Rights. Therefore, while Beard Papas offers some territorial protection, numerous exceptions and reserved rights can impact a franchisee's competitive landscape.
During a limited period for site selection, Beard Papas agrees not to grant a third party the license or right to establish a Beard Papa's Shop within the Site Selection Area, which is identified by the franchisee. This period commences on the Site Selection Acknowledgment Date and expires 60 calendar days after. However, the terms in the Franchise Agreement take precedence over the Site Selection Acknowledgment in case of any inconsistencies.