Which article in the Beard Papas Franchise Agreement discusses transfer of the franchise?
Beard_Papas Franchise · 2025 FDDAnswer from 2025 FDD Document
"Transfer Fee" shall have the meaning defined in Article 14.C.(11) of this Agreement. The Transfer Fee is a fixed sum of $15,000.
ARTICLE 2 GRANT OF FRANCHISE
2.A. GRANT OF FRANCHISE
Franchisee has requested that Franchisor grant to Franchisee the non-exclusive license and right to develop, own and operate a Beard Papa's Shop from a fixed Shop Location located within a specified territory. Relying on the representations made by Franchisee and/or Franchisee's Owners in any submitted application and during the application process, and subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement, Franchisee's request has been approved by Franchisor, subject to the following terms and conditions:
(1) During the Term of this Agreement and subject to the rights of Franchisor including, but not limited to, the Reserved Rights, Franchisor grants to Franchisee and Franchisee accepts, the nonexclusive license, right and obligation to develop and operate, one Beard Papa's Shop in conformity with the System and this Agreement from a single fixed shop location, selected by Franchisee but requiring the approval of Franchisor ("Franchisee's Shop Location") and, as designated by Franchisor in Franchisor's discretion and Reasonable Business Judgment, within a Designated Territory;
(2) If, as of the Effective Date, Franchisee has selected a proposed Shop Location that Franchisor approves as Franchisee's Shop Location, then Franchisee's Shop Location and Designated Territory, if any, shall be identified in Schedule 1 of this Agreement.
To be effective, Schedule 1 must be completed and signed by Franchisor.
Franchisee's execution of Schedule 1 with a specific location for Franchisee's Shop Location shall constitute Franchisee's obligation to develop and operate the Franchised Business at the designated Franchisee Shop Location;
[Item 23: RECEIPTS]
(8) Unless Franchisee has met the requirements of Article 3.E. within the five year period immediately preceding the Transfer, the transferee, at its expense, must improve, modify, refurbish, renovate, remodel, and/or otherwise upgrade Franchisee's Beard Papa's Shop Facility to conform to the then current standards and specifications of Franchisor, and the transferee must complete such improvements, modifications, refurbishments, renovations, remodeling, and/or upgrading within the time period Franchisor reasonably specifies;
(9) Franchisee, each Owner, and each Spouse shall remain liable for all obligations to Franchisor set forth in this Agreement, except that, following a Transfer that fully complies with this Article 14.C., Franchisee, each Owner, and each Spouse shall not be obligated to pay any Royalty Fees and Advertising Contributions which accrue following the date of the approved Transfer;
(10) At the transferee's expense, the transferee, and the transferee's Managing Owner, managers
and/or any other applicable employees of transferee's Beard Papa's Shop must complete any training programs then in effect for franchisees of Beard Papa's Shops upon terms and conditions set forth in this Agreement or as Franchisor otherwise reasonably requires;
(11) Franchisee must pay the Transfer Fee to Franchisor, which is a fixed sum of $15,000 (the "Transfer Fee");
(12) Franchisor's approval of the material terms and conditions of the Transfer, and Franchisor determines in Franchisor's Reasonable Business Judgment that the price and terms of payment are not so burdensome as to be detrimental to the future operations of the Franchised Business by the transferee;
(13) Transferee's employees, directors, officers, independent contractors, and agents who will have access to Confidential Information shall execute the Confidentiality Agreement attached hereto as Exhibit 2;
(14) Franchisee entering into an agreement with Franchisor agreeing to subordinate any obligations of transferee to make installment payments of the purchase price to Franchisee to the transferee's obligations to Franchisor, including, without limitation, transferee's obligations with respect to Royalty Fees and Advertising Contributions;
[Item 23: RECEIPTS]
NEW YORK FRANCHISE AND DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT AMENDMENT
Amendments to the Beard Papa's Franchise Agreement
In recognition of the requirements of the New York General Business Law, Article 33, Sections 680 through 695, and of the regulations promulgated thereunder (N.Y. Comp. Code R. & Regs., tit. 13, §§ 200.1 through 201.16), the parties to the attached Muginoho International, Inc. Franchise Agreement (the "Franchise Agreement") and, if Franchisor and Franchisee both sign the Muginoho International, Inc. Multi-Unit Development Agreement (the "Development Agreement"), as follows:
-
- Under Article 14.C. of the Franchise Agreement, under the heading "Conditions for Approval of Transfer," the subarticle 14.C(6) is supplemented with the addition of the following language:
- ; provided, however, that all rights and causes of action arising in favor of Franchisee from the provisions of New York General Business Law Sections 680-695 and the regulations issued thereunder, shall remain in force; it being the intent of this provision that the non-waiver provisions of N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law Sections 687.4 and 687.5 be satisfied.
-
- Under Article 15.B. of the Franchise Agreement, under the heading "Conditions for Renewal," the subarticle 15.B(8) is supplemented with the addition of the following language:
- ; provided, however, that all rights and causes of action arising in favor of Franchisee from the provisions of New York General Business Law Sections 680-695 and the regulations issued thereunder, shall remain in force; it being the intent of this provision that the non-waiver provisions of N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law Sections 687.4 and 687.5 be satisfied.
-
- Article 18 of the Franchise Agreement and, if Franchisee executes a Development Agreement, Section 7 of the Development Agreement, under the heading "Enforcement and Construction," shall be supplemented by the addition of the following new subarticle 18.Z. to the Franchise Agreement and Section 7.24 of the Development Agreement:
Nothing in this Agreement should be considered a waiver of any right conferred upon franchisee by New York General Business Law, Sections 680-695.
[Item 23: RECEIPTS]
A-7, Cerritos, California 90703;
WHEREAS, the Beard Papa's Franchise System relates to and includes shops featuring fresh and natural cream puffs and a limited selection of other desserts and beverages and other menu items that the Franchisor authorizes under the "Beard Papa's" name and marks (the "Intended Use");
WHEREAS, Tenant is a franchisee of Franchisor pursuant to the terms of a Franchise Agreement entered into between Franchisor and Tenant (the "Franchise Agreement") and the Leased Premises is to be used and operated by Tenant for the purpose of developing, establishing and operating a Beard Papa's Shop in accordance with the Beard Papa's franchise system; and
WHEREAS, Franchisor and Franchisor's successors and assigns (collectively referred to as "Franchisor") is/are intended third party beneficiaries of this Rider.
NOW THEREFORE, Landlord and Tenant acknowledge and agree to the following:
-
- This Rider supplements and amends the Lease. In the event of any inconsistency or conflict between the terms of this Rider and the Lease, the terms of this Rider shall prevail. Landlord and Tenant acknowledge that the rights set forth in this Rider may not be reduced, modified or altered without the express written consent of Franchisor.
-
- Landlord and Tenant both agree that Tenant shall not be permitted to transfer, sublease, encumber and/or otherwise assign Tenant's interests in the Lease and/or the Leased Premises without the prior written consent of Franchisor. Without limitation to the foregoing, among other things, Tenant agrees that if Tenant wishes to transfer any interests in the Lease or the Leased Premises that Tenant must request the written
consent of Franchisor. If Tenant requests Landlord's consent to Tenant's amendment, transfer and/or assignment of Tenant's interests in the Lease and/or the Leased Premises and if Landlord is inclined to approve of such amendment, transfer and/or assignment that Landlord shall condition Landlord's approval upon Tenant also obtaining written consent from Franchisor.
[Item 23: RECEIPTS]
(15) Franchisee and transferee acknowledge and agree that Franchisor's approval of the Transfer indicates only that the transferee meets, or Franchisor waived, the criteria established by Franchisor for franchisees as of the time of such transfer, and Franchisor's approval thereof does not constitute a warranty or guaranty by Franchisor, express or implied, of the suitability of the terms of sale, successful operation, or profitability of the Franchised Business;
(16) Franchisee and transferee acknowledge and agree that Franchisor's approval of the Transfer at issue does not constitute Franchisor's approval of future or other Transfers or the waiver of the requirement that Franchisor must approve such future or other Transfers in accordance with this Agreement;
(17) The Transfer must be made in compliance with all applicable laws;
(18) The Transfer of the Franchised Business, the lease for Franchisee's Beard Papa's Shop Facility, Shop Location and the assets of the Franchised Business shall be made only in conjunction with a Transfer of this Agreement, approved by Franchisor in accordance with and subject to this Article 14 and the terms and conditions of this Agreement; and
(19) Franchisor's consent to a Transfer of any interest that is subject to the restrictions of this Agreement shall not constitute a waiver of any claims it may have against Franchisee or deemed a waiver of Franchisor's right to demand strict and exact compliance with this Agreement by the transferee.
14.D. DEATH OR DISABILITY OF FRANCHISEE OR AN OWNER
(1) If Franchisee is an individual and not a Corporate Entity, upon the death or permanent disability of Franchisee, the executor, administrator, conservator or other personal representative of Franchisee, must appoint a manager that meets the equivalent of an Operating Manager within a reasonable time, which shall not exceed 30 days from the date of death or permanent disability. The appointed manager (as applicable) must serve and qualify as an Operating Manager and attend and successfully complete the Training Program within 60 days of the appointment. If Franchisee's
[Item 23: RECEIPTS]
HAWAII FRANCHISE AGREEMENT AMENDMENT
Amendments to the Beard Papa's Franchise Agreement
In recognition of the requirements of the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law, the undersigned agree to the following modifications to the Muginoho International, Inc. Franchise Agreement (the "Franchise Agreement"), as follows:
- Sub-Article 14.C.(6). Sub-article 14.C.(6), under the Article section titled "Conditions for Approval of Transfer," is supplemented by the addition of the following language:
; provided, however, that all rights enjoyed by Franchisee and any causes of action arising in Franchisee's favor from the provisions of the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law, shall remain in force; it being the intent of this provision that the non-waiver provisions of the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law be satisfied; and
The Hawaii Franchise Investment Law provides rights to the franchisee concerning non-renewal, termination and transfer of the Franchise Agreement. If this Sub-article contains a provision that is inconsistent with the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law, the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law will control.
- Sub-Article 15.B.(8). Sub-article 15.B.(8), under the Article section titled "Conditions for Renewal," is supplemented by the addition of the following:
; provided, however, that all rights enjoyed by Franchisee and any causes of action arising in Franchisee's favor from the provisions of the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law, shall remain in force; it being the intent of this provision that the non-waiver provisions of the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law be satisfied; and
The Hawaii Franchise Investment Law provides rights to the franchisee concerning non-renewal, termination and transfer of the Franchise Agreement. If this subarticle contains a provision that is inconsistent with the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law, the Hawaii Franchise Investment Law will control.
[Item 1: THE FRANCHISOR AND ANY PARENTS, PREDECESSORS AND AFFILIATES]
ITEM 1 THE FRANCHISOR AND ANY PARENTS, PREDECESSORS AND AFFILIATES
Muginoho International, Inc., the franchisor of the Beard Papa's franchise is referred to in this franchise disclosure document (the "Disclosure Document") as "we", "us" or "our" as the context requires. A franchisee is referred to in this Disclosure Document as "you" and "your" as the context requires. If you are a corporation, partnership or other legal entity (a "Corporate Entity"), our Franchise Agreement will also apply to your individual owners, shareholders, members, officers, directors and other principals.
The Franchisor
We are a New York corporation established on September 24, 2002. Our principal place of business is 11443 South Street Suite A-7, Cerritos, California 90703. We conduct business under our corporate name Muginoho International, Inc. and under the Beard Papa's trade name. Our business is operating the Beard Papa's Shop franchise system and granting franchises to third parties like you to develop and operate a Shop. Our business operates the Beard Papa's Shop franchise system in the United States, Canada, Vietnam, Philippines, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia. We began offering franchises in the United States in December 2004. Other than as discussed above, we are not in any other business, we have not conducted business in any other line of business, we do not conduct or operate a Franchised Business of the type to be operated by a franchisee, and we have not offered or sold franchises in any other line of business. We do not have any predecessors. Our registered agents for service of process are disclosed in Exhibit B of this Disclosure Document.
The Franchised Business
[Item 23: RECEIPTS]
- (4) The transferee shall be bound by all terms and conditions of this Agreement, and each owner of the transferee and their respective spouses shall personally execute the Owner and Spouse Agreement and Guaranty in the form attached to this Agreement as Exhibit 1.
Each owner of the transferee shall also be required to execute such further agreements designated by Franchisor whereby the proposed transferee assumes each and every obligation and responsibility of Franchisee as set forth in this Agreement;
(5) All obligations of Franchisee under this Agreement and the Ancillary Agreements shall be assumed by the transferee, each individual owner of transferee, and their respective spouses in a manner satisfactory to Franchisor;
(6) Franchisee, each Owner, and each Spouse must execute the General Release
Source: Item 9 — FRANCHISEE'S OBLIGATIONS (FDD pages 30–31)
What This Means (2025 FDD)
According to the 2025 Beard Papas Franchise Disclosure Document, Article 14.C of the Franchise Agreement outlines the conditions for approval of a transfer. Several sub-articles within Article 14.C detail specific requirements and considerations for transferring a Beard Papas franchise.
These conditions include requirements that the transferee meets the current standards for franchisees, completes required training programs, and assumes all obligations under the Franchise Agreement. The franchisee must pay a $15,000 transfer fee to Beard Papas. The franchisor's approval hinges on assessing the transferee's qualifications and the financial terms of the transfer to ensure they are not detrimental to the business's future operations.
Amendments to the New York and Hawaii franchise agreements further specify that rights and causes of action arising from their respective state laws regarding franchise investments remain in force, particularly concerning non-waiver provisions related to transfer rights. These amendments ensure that franchisees in New York and Hawaii retain their statutory rights, even when transferring the franchise. The franchisor's approval of a transfer does not constitute a warranty of the franchise's future success or a waiver of the franchisor's right to enforce the agreement's terms against the transferee.