Where must any cause of action related to the Alloy franchise agreement be brought if it's not subject to arbitration?
Alloy Franchise · 2025 FDDAnswer from 2025 FDD Document
Subject to Section 10.N, any cause of action, claim, suit or demand allegedly arising from or related to the terms of this Agreement or the relationship of the parties must be brought in the Illinois federal or state court for the Designated Area in which you are located.
-
- The Acknowledgment Addendum attached to the Area Development Agreement (and specifically stating that it is not for use in the State of Illinois) is unenforceable under Illinois law because it may have the effect of forcing a franchisee to waive or release certain rights that you as a franchisee have under the Illinois Franchise Disclosure Act, 815 IL § 705.
-
- Section 10.G (1) is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following:
Applicable Law and Waiver. Subject to our rights under federal trademark laws and the parties' rights under the Federal Arbitration Act in accordance with Section 15.01 of this Agreement, the parties' rights under this Agreement, and the relationship between the parties is governed by, and will be interpreted in accordance with, the laws (statutory and otherwise) of Illinois.
Source: Item 23 — RECEIPTS (FDD pages 69–245)
What This Means (2025 FDD)
According to Alloy's 2025 Franchise Disclosure Document, the location where a cause of action, claim, suit, or demand must be brought depends on the franchisee's location and whether the action is subject to arbitration. For franchisees located in Illinois, any legal action arising from the franchise agreement or the relationship between the parties must be brought in the Illinois federal or state court for the designated area in which the franchisee is located, subject to Section 10.N of the agreement. For franchisees in Washington, if litigation is not precluded by the franchise agreement, a franchisee may bring an action or proceeding arising out of or in connection with the sale of franchises, or a violation of the Washington Franchise Investment Protection Act, in Washington.
For prospective Alloy franchisees, this means that the location for resolving legal disputes can vary. Generally, franchise agreements often include clauses specifying the jurisdiction and venue for any legal actions. The Illinois addendum explicitly states that legal actions must be brought in Illinois federal or state court within the franchisee's designated area. However, the Washington addendum provides an exception, allowing franchisees in Washington to bring actions related to franchise sales or violations of the Washington Franchise Investment Protection Act in Washington state courts.
It is important to note that these venue provisions are subject to certain conditions and exceptions. For instance, the Illinois addendum is subject to Section 10.N of the agreement, which may contain additional stipulations or limitations. Additionally, the Washington addendum applies only if litigation is not precluded by the franchise agreement, suggesting that arbitration or other alternative dispute resolution methods may be required in some cases. Franchisees should carefully review the franchise agreement and any applicable addenda to understand their rights and obligations regarding dispute resolution.
Furthermore, the FDD indicates that the enforceability of certain provisions, such as waivers of punitive damages and jury trials, may vary depending on state law. In California, for example, such waivers may not be enforceable. Therefore, prospective franchisees should consult with legal counsel to understand the specific laws and regulations that may affect their franchise agreement and dispute resolution options.